"Let’s compare and contrast 2007 and 2010:
- We have lost 7.8 million jobs since then.
- The unemployment rate is 9.7% versus 4.5%.
- Total unemployed workers are now 15.7 million versus 6.5 million.
- Real personal income less government transfers is lower by 6.5%, or $624 billion.
- Real retail sales have rebounded just 4% from their lows and are still down 9% from the 2007 peak.
- Consumer credit for February showed another sharp retrenchment of -5.6B.
- Consumer bankruptcies for March were the highest level since 2005.
- There is a glaring $1.5 TRILLION hole in the consumer balance sheet.
- Home foreclosures surged 19% last month and are at their highest level since 2005.
- The consumer’s largest asset (housing) is down 33% since 2007."
The index closed down at 89.49 this Friday.
This has three implications for Ireland:
- US problems on consumer side pale in comparison with those found here. We had much deeper contractions in housing asset prices, much greater exposure to housing in the overall composition of household assets portfolios, much more severe acceleration in unemployment, much deeper collapse in disposable after-tax incomes (courtesy of twin forces: Government tax policies and indirect tax hikes, plus wages compressions), lack of compensating increases in Government transfers, more restrictive personal bankruptcy laws, greater consumer leveraging, and steeper fall-off in credit availability;
- As I wrote before (here), household investment is the core leading indicator of recoveries and recessions; and
- Our cohort of official commentariate on matter economic has been very eager to drum up the stories about 'return of consumer spending' in recent weeks.
In my view, what we are seeing is a temporary uplift in sales of some items that are overdue replacement (due to amortization) after 3 years of collapsed sales. This, folks, is not a recovery. It is a dead-cat-bounce... When you hit concrete at 100mphs, the bounce can be substantial. But it hardly qualifies as a 'structural improvement'. Looks like some folks might be deluding themselves...