Saturday, May 29, 2010

Economics 29/05/2010: EBS - taxpayers are on the hook, again

One really has to start worrying about the going-ons at the DofF, the CBFSAI and in the Government. After all, over recent weeks we have been told that:
  1. The leadership in this country is finally getting its hand on the pulse of the financial sector and the economy (a tale that emerged back in March when Minister for Finance, the Governor of the CB and the FR made back to back statements concerning the plans for the banking sector stabilization, and subsequently went on to assure the nation that all is now going to be fine);
  2. Ireland has turned the corner (we've heard this in its various variants since May 2009);
  3. With Nama working overtime, lending is about to be restored across the nation;
  4. There are no more nasty surprises (apart from the ever-shifting capital targets in the Anglo);
  5. That banks can now sort themselves out and hence there will be no need for a sweeping Guarantee extension comes September;
  6. That Ireland is so far ahead of the PIIGS curve, it is reckless and dangerous, and erroneous, to claim otherwise.
Well, as of today we, the taxpayers, own another banking institution - the EBS - which, up until now was regarded as the least sickly of the Irish banks. Per Irish Times report today: "The Government’s move came after the society failed to attract private investors. The State now seems set to invest up to €875 million in total over the next 10 years."

Pardon my French, but what the h***ll is going on in our circles of power? One would naturally expect the Government and the regulators responsible for the banking sector to be in a daily contact with the institution, like EBS, while it is engaged in a major talks with potential buyers. And one would expect the talks to progress over time, with some clear indications as to whether the deal was likely or not. A sudden release of this new information is, therefore,
  • either a reflection of the fact that our banking sector authorities did not have a clue as to the progression of the talks - in which case they once again failed to 'keep their hand' on the patient's pulse; or
  • they have at the very least did not disclose pertinent information to the markets and the public as to the state of these talks.
Either way, the news that the taxpayers are once again stuck for ca €1 billion in bailout funds (more than the amount of €600mln the Spanish Government had to inject in one of its banks, triggering a massive run on Spanish markets) without any, and I repeat, any public official making the matter public until the deal was done!

Of course, another remarkable thing about the deal is that it comes on foot of Nama being deployed in the market. Last year, myself, Brian Lucey, Peter Mathews, Karl Whelan and others have warned that nationalization of the failing Irish banks was the least costly option for their recapitalization that should be pursued. Nationalization of EBS would have cost no more than €650-800 million and would have led to a 100% ownership of the bank by the State. In return, we could have imposed a speedy reform on the bank's board and management, and actively repaired its balancesheet.

Instead, we have paid countless millions for it through Nama, shelled out almost €1 billion in direct capital commitments, supplied it with a state Guarantee worth well in excess of €200 million in risk-related implicit costs, and still control only 51% of the bank. We are now left with a quasi-state asset that cannot be reformed and is at a risk of being left to linger like a zombie stuck between private markets and the politicos.

One wonders, will anyone, responsible for Nama and the rest of our banks policy ever be held accountable for this waste?


Anonymous said...

One gets the impression that the unaccountable individuals making these calls under the cover of "market confidentiality" and without having even the modest accountability afforded by the FOI act have totally lost sight of the enormity of the sums they are dealing with.
If asked right now how many politico's and senior civil servants could put the correct number of 0's after the first number. Back in the 80's the revenue generated by the Irish distillers site in Midleton generated a fair portion the day to day hard cash to keep the country afloat. That memory of the value of cash has been lost by the current incumbents.
I read your blog regularly and respect the effort that you put into the data and figures you use to support your contentions.Pity others aren't quiet up to or able to comprehend them and the implications they contain for our future. JPC

jpc said...

Sorry the pointI was trying to make above was the number of zeros to make a billion. I really dont people comprehend the consequence of adding an extra zero. The site below is quiet illuminating on the subjet