15/11/2012: The impossibility of Greek 2020 targets

Euromoney headlines today with an article on the impossibility of 120% debt/GDP ratio target for Greece (link here). It so happens that few days ago, I crunched through my own estimates on Greek debt holdings and dynamics. The below is based on data from:

• Goldman Sachs Research (debt allocations)
• IMF WEO
• My own scenario 2 for growth shock

Here are the institutions holding Greek debt: 

Using IMF scenario (best case scenario, based on current 2013-2017 growth projections and 2018-2020 growth at 2017 growth rate of 4.586% nominal - representing the highest annual rate projected by the IMF for 2012-2017) and my own adverse scenario (assuming growth of 2.84% on average annually in 2014-2020 as opposed to the IMF assumed average growth of 3.59% on average), the table below shows summary of forecasts for 2020 debt outrun under:

1. Status quo - implying 2020 outrun of 137% debt/GDP ratio in the case of IMF own projections and 148.5% debt/GDP ratio in my scenario 2;
2. Case of imposing 75% haircut on ECB-held Greek Government debt (a writedown of €33.52bn) resulting in IMF-consistent scenario estimate of 123.2% debt/GDP ratio in 2020 and 134.1% debt/GDP ratio under my adverse growth scenario 2;
3. Case of imposing - in addition to a 75% writedown of ECB-held debt - a writedown of 25% of EFSF-held Greek debt, delivering savings / cuts to the debt of €62.74bn - and yielding 2020 Government debt/GDP ratio of 111.2% in the case of IMF projections for growth (scenario 1) and 121.4% in the case of my scenario 2.

Thus, the bottom line is: unless 

1. IMF projections for 2.84% average growth in 2014-2017, plus my assumption that in 2017-2020 Greek economy were to growth at the 2017 IMF-projected 4.59% hold, a 75% haircut on ECB-held Greek Government debt will not be enough to get Greek Government debt/GDP ratio anywhere close to 120%.
2. To ensure probabilistically likely delivery on 2020 target of 120% debt/GDP ratio, Greece requires much more than a writedown of 75% of its ECB-held liabilities, but will most likely require some sort of action on EFSF side as well.

13/11/2012: Irish CPI v Euro Area: September 2012

In the previous post I covered overall dynamics of Irish consumer prices in October. Now, let's take a quick look at comparatives across the euro area. These are reported by the CSO with one month lag, so all we have is September 2012 year on year changes in prices. For comparative reasons, I also put y/y changes in prices for January 2012. The chart below shows the difference between Irish inflation and euro area overall inflation, with positive numbers signifying by how much Irish CPI changes in specific category exceeds euro area overall CPI changes for that category. Negative numbers show by how much euro area CPI changes exceeds Irish CPI changes.

Of notable trends/patterns:

• Irish overall consumer price inflation HICP (2.4% annual in September 2012) was below that for the EA17 (2.6%) and below EU27 (2.7%).
• Ireland also posted lower inflation in September in Food and-alcoholic beverages, clothing and footware, Furnishings, household equipment and maintenance, Health, Recreation and culture, and Restaurants and hotels.
• Ireland posted identical (to EA17) inflation in Alcoholic beverages & tobacco.
• Ireland's inflation was in excess of that for the EA17 in Housing, water, electricty, gas & other fuels, Transport, Communications, education (by a massive 9.3 percentage points) and Miscellaneous goods & services.
• Higher inflation rates in Ireland have accelerated in September, compared to January in only two categories: Housing, water, electricity, gas and other fuels, and Education.

In annual terms, Ireland is now in inflation territory since August 2010, with the peak rate of 3.11% in April 2011 and the current rate running at 1.20% - a modest inflationary environment, which means that our nominal GNP, were it to post 0% real growth is expanding at the rate closer to 1% nominally - a massive under-shooting of the rate of nominal growth required to deflate our debt pile.

13/11/2012: Consumer Prices in Ireland: October 2012

Consumer price index for October 2012, Ireland released last week chows broad continuation of the previously established trends, namely above-average inflation in state-controlled sectors, albeit the overall rate of the state-sanctioned rip-off of consumers is now moderating relative to previous months.

Overall CPI index dipped to 101.5 (2011 base year) in October compared to 101.6 in September, representing a mom change of -0.1% and y/y rise of 1.20%. 3mo average through October is at +0.36% rise on previous 3mo period and is up 1.60% y/y.

Charts below illustrate:

One thing is clear from the charts above: despite the economy still in trouble, cost of living in Ireland is now at the levels comparable with those attained in early 2008.

Looking at decomposition by broad category:

• Price index in Food & non-alcoholic beverages category rose from 100.6 in September to 101.0 in October. The index is now up 1% y/y and 3mo average through October 2012 is 0.7% above the same period average a year ago.
• Alcoholic beverages & tobacco prices index is slightly down from 103.7 in September 2012 to 103.5 in October 2012, but the index is still up 3.5% y/y and index 3mo average through October 2012 is up 3.57% on the same period a year ago. The index annual inflation was driven primarily by rises in price sof cigarettes (+6.9 y/y) and Other tobacco (+7.9% y/y)
• Clothing and footware sub-category index is up from 99.5 in September to 100.5 in October. The sub-index is now up 1.01% y/y and its 3mo average through October 2012 is 0.64% ahead of the 3mo average for the same period in 2011. Garments were the only sub-category of goods in this category that showed y/y inflation (+2%), with other sub-categories posting deflation.
• In Housing, water, electricity, gas and other fuels category, prices index rose from 96.8 in September to 98 in October, the index is up 1.24% m/m and is down 3.26% y/y. 3mo average through October is down 2.41% on a year ago. Mortgage interest posted a robust 18.1% decline y/y, but this decline is distributed unevenly with adjustable rate mortgages rising in cost, whiel tracker mortgages benefiting from ECB easy monetary policies. Meanwhile, largest y/y increases were recorded in Electricity (+8.7%), Gas (+9.3%) and Liquid fuels (+13.4%).
• Furnishings, Household equipment and routine maintenance sub-index is down marginally from 97.4 in September to 97.2 in October. The sub-index is down 2.70% y/y and its 3mo average through October is down 2.53% y/y. Nine out of eleven sub-categories of goods and services posted deflation y/y in October.
• Health prices index moderated from 100.4 to 100.2 m/m in October and is up only 0.3% y/y with 3mo average through October up 0.47% y/y. In Health, largest price increases in October in annual terms were in Other Medical Products (+2.9%) and Other medical and Paramedical Services (other than Doctors' fees) (+3.2%).
• Transport sub-index fell significantly from 109.3 in September to 106.3 in October (down 2.74% m/m). However, the sub-index is still up 5.77% y/y and 3mo average through October 2012 is now up 7.34% on the same period of 2011. In Transport, largest increases in prices, annually, were in Petrol (+12.4%), Diesel (+11.1%), Motor Tax (+10.8%), Bus Fares (+9.2%), passenger Transport by Sea and Inland Waterway (+5.4%) and Combined Passenger Transport (+6.2%).
• Communications prices sub-index moderated from 97.4 in September to 96.6 in October, down 3.40% y/y and down 2.67% y/y in terms of 3mo average through October. here, Postal services went up in price 1.5% y/y, while Telephone & telefax equipment and services were down in prices 3.6% y/y.
• Recreation and culture prices sub-index rose from 98.7 in September to 99.2 in October, with an annual inflation registering at 6.73%. 3mo average through October was up 8.63% y/y.
• Education costs rose at a monthly inflation of 4.6%, up 6.73 y/y in October to 104.6, while 3mo average through October 2012 was up 8.63% y/y. In education inflation was primarily diven by Secondary education (+2.5% y/y), Tertiary Education (+6.5%) and Education not definable by level (+6.6%).
• Restaurants and hotels price index  was at 01.6 in October, down from 10.2 in September but still up 0.99% y/y, same rate of inflation as 3mo average through October 2012.
• Miscellaneous goods and services sub-category price index rose from 104.2 in September to 105.2 in October and is up 5.62% y/y, with 3mo average through October 2012 up 5.40% on the same period a year ago. Here, health insurance costs were up 15.9% y/y and insurance connected with transport was up 4.7% y/y. Other services inflation run at 22.8% y/y in October.

 In terms of historical rates of inflation, charts below show current price indices for all main categories of goods and services relative to 1976 and 2007 readings.

12/11/2012: Quick reading list of late...

Some of my reading from today - worth checking out:

"Debunking Two Nate Silver Myths" from Scientopia.org lays our Bayesian foundations for Nat Silver's forecasting efforts. But in reality, the blog post deals with a deeper issue - the way we interpret predictive models.

"Mathematics, Marriage, and High explosives: Why There Is No Nobel Prize for Math" is a good short post on Shapley and Roth Nobel MP in Economics win, but the post repeats the myth (I am guilty of having told this one myself before) that is solidly debunked here.

A cool paper "The Collapse of the Soviet Union and the Productivity of American Mathematicians" - I recall the years of 1993-1997 when the UCLA maths department welcomed numerous faculty members from the former USSR and Eastern Block.

Foreign Policy superb article on the potential geo-political implications of the opening of the Arctic Passage: "Open Seas". The historical perspective absolutely brilliantly drawn.

NYTimes on "The science and art of listening" quote: "The difference between the sense of hearing and the skill of listening is attention" 

Aside from that - re-reading Vladimir Vonovich's "Moscow 2042" was a delight...

And I will be blogging on academic papers I read... so stay tuned.

11/11/2012: 4 interesting charts on investment portfolia compositions

four charts showing differences between the euro area and US portfolia compositions prior to the crisis, during the crisis and now (via Morgan Stanley):

Households:

 So for households, US portfolia are relatively balanced at near 50:50 split on risk and 'riskless' sides. equity ownership is low by historical standards, but that is probably offset by higher exposures to government bonds, corporate debt, government bonds and commodities as well as funds. Lower deposits holdings compared to euro area suggest lesser precautionary savings.

On euro area side, we have dramatic long-term decline in equities holdings and structural rise in deposits and cash. Precautionary savings motive is very pronounced.

Pension Funds:

Charts below show different pattern for equities holdings in these funds against household trends above:

Interestingly, Euro area households and pension funds are relatively similar in terms of longer trend of equities holdings, suggesting that either the objectives of both types of investors are convergent (retirement expectations and demographics weighing heavily on both) or structurally, equities markets in Europe are simply not attractive to both types of investors.

Much to speculate about here... especially behaviorally...

11/11/2012: Property prices bust 2008-2012

House prices changes peak-to-2009 then 2009-present:

Via Goldman Sachs.

With core driver - fundamentals:

Note Spain (my analysis): fundamentals-driven house prices are yet to travel down to below Irish markets drop... This, of course, is not a precise fully deterministic model (feed-back loops from unemployment to house prices are also going from house prices to unemployment), but it is clear that Spanish property is still 'overvalued' grossly relative to fundamentals.

And here's some other 'bad' news:

Taking the comparative above (again, my reading of the chart), a combination of fiscal direction and debt levels implies Irish house prices are still overvalued by up to 20% or so. Spanish ones - by about 10-15%...

Full note here.

Note: these are not my forecasts. I am only pointing out the direction that the above figures above imply in my view for the property markets.

10/11/2012: 'Special' case redux?

Just in case Angela Merkel reads EU Commission research... here's a chart summarizing the 'structural' adjustments to-date courtesy of JMP Research:

And the chart shows that 'special' Ireland:

• Delivered second largest drop in unit labour costs in the periphery (much of that, as in Greece's case and Spain due to massive spikes in unemployment)
• Produced 4th largest (or second lowest) improvement in current account dynamics and had 3rd highest increase in unemployment.

In other words, as with fiscal adjustments, our 'structural' gains are far from being 'special' or exemplary, but rather represent below average levels of achievement compared to other 'peripheral' economies.

And in case you need more, here's a bit on wages 'moderation' in Ireland:

The chart above shows pretty clearly that while Ireland claims to have achieved tremendous gains in labour costs competitiveness, in reality our gains are only spectacular if we forget the rapid inflation experienced in 2000-2009. Let's run some maths: between 2000 and 2012:

• Greek nominal labour costs relative to EU average fell 0.37%
• Irish rose 7.69%
• Portuguese fell 4.21%
• Spanish rose 6.4%
• Dutch rose 8.9%
• Italian rose 1.97%
• French rose 1% and
• German fell 16.36%

In other words, Ireland's labour costs still are up more than for any other peripheral state and, in fact, are only lower relative to the EU average against the Netherlands. Spot anything 'special' here?

10/11/2012: Dublin's Shame

This week saw perhaps the most important FT article on Ireland's crisis (link) titled Dublin's Shame, the article highlights the issue of grotesquely over-exaggerated pensions of Irish failed bankers. The point it touches upon - by itself - is not a minor one. But what is most important is the fact that FT takes a clearly only feasible ethical position on the issue and, put frankly, throws it in the face of not only the Irish banking establishment (on which the article focuses), but the Irish Government that is sheepishly incapable of any response to the issue that would have been congruent with the normal tenets of morality in any normal society.

"Public shaming may be the only recourse available to the government. Some argue that the pension funds should stop paying these executives, daring them to sue. Alternatively, Dublin could raise a levy on the richest pensions. But, however justified the resentment, either step would be wrong. Governments should not tear up contracts or tweak laws just to target a few. If the directors are to be penalised for their acts, this should happen in the civil courts."

Alas, public shaming is something our Government refuses to engage in, judging by the statement made this week on the issue by the AIB owner - Minister Noonan. And, sadly, in Ireland, there is not a chance the civil courts will see the face of the vast majority of the reckless, incompetent and entitlement-driven elites.

10/11/2012: GS on Fiscal Cliff

Earlier this week I posted few assorted analytical thoughts from various source on the US Fiscal Cliff and earlier today I posted on Goldman Sachs summary of 3 core global risks.

Here are four snapshots from Goldman Sachs on US key risks:

Fiscal cliff:

Tax hikes:

Debt ceiling:

Updated: Merrill Lynch note on US elections outcome is a superb read: here.

And Citi detailed forecasts out to 2020 from the 'cliff': here.

10/11/2012: Shorter-term divergence for Europe?

For what it is worth:

Shorter-term divergence again disfavors Europe... and even worse... UK:

10/11/2012: Age of Great Rotation?

Merrill Lynch calling the turn from the Age of Deleveraging to the Age of Great Rotation: "History shows that the beginning of every great bull market in equities (1920s, 1950s, and 1980s) has coincided with a major inflection point in the trend of long-term bond yields (see Chart 3)."

"If in 2013 jobs and credit validate Bernanke’s success in his “War against Deflation,” an era of rotation out of fixed income and into equities could begin."

That's a load of 'ifs' and 'cans'. In reality, there will be such a shift at some point in time. Only question is the following one: will the Age of Deleveraging (not called 'Great Deleveraging' by the ML, note) going to be so short-lived that by the end of 2013 Ben's cash printing will be sufficient to drive down real economic debt in the US down significantly enough to generate a new upswing in consumer credit (after all, there will be no US growth absent credit growth).

ML are pretty darn optimistic on this:
"The strong performance of US real estate, bank stocks, and distressed European assets this year suggests to us that a stealth rotation has actually begun. The fiscal cliff may temporarily derail the journey, but in our view the destination remains a favorable one for financial assets. Our core asset allocation is bullish equities and credit, bearish bonds and neutral commodities."

ML own view is a bit dented by the evidence in the chart above on the 1920s-1930s markets transitions relative to Treasury yields... Of course, as today, the 1920s-1930s period is precisely characterized by a long-term Great Deleveraging dynamics. Denying that the current state of the economy is characterized by potentially the same forces is a bit reminiscent of the Greenspan's 'over-exuberance' view.

Link to the ML research note: here.

10/11/2012: Three core risks: via Goldman Sachs

Neat summary from Goldman Sachs on 3 core risks: