Economics 1/7/10: Finland - Broadband access is a universal right

An interesting follow up to our Digital Economy Rankings 2010 released jointly by EIU and IBM's Institute for Business Value earlier this week (see here for global results and here for detailed data on Ireland).

Finland - ranked 4th in the world this year by DER2010 - has just announced that its residents will have the legal right to broadband access. A law passed in October 2009 came into force today requiring all telecomms providers to offer 24/7-on high-speed internet connections to all of the country's 5.3 million residents. A minimum speed of at least 1 megabit per second must be guaranteed.

For comparison,

Finland achieved the following scores in Connectivity and Technology Infrastructure category (relating to quality and supply of broadband):

• Overall Connectivity & Technology Infrastructure score = 8.0/10.0
• Broadband penetration = 7.0
• Broadband quality = 1.0
• Broadband affordability = 9.0
• Internet user penetration = 9.0
• International internet bandwidth = 10.0
• Internet security = 10.0

In comparison, Ireland scores, relating to broadband) in this category were:

• Overall Connectivity & Technology Infrastructure score = 7.20/10.0
• Broadband penetration = 5.0
• Broadband quality = 1.0
• Broadband affordability = 9.0
• Internet user penetration = 7.0
• International internet bandwidth = 10.0
• Internet security = 10.0

Spot the difference?

Economics 29/06/2010: Digital economy rankings 2010: Ireland details

Updated: here is the link to the actual report.

Ireland results, as promised.

High level stuff first:
Good move - 1 rank improvement overall, improvements in 3 sub-categories, but slipping in 3 other.

Compared to peers:
Note: New Zealand has shown remarkable consistent gains over the last 10 years, moving to top 10 position this year for the first time.

Next, consider all categories changes in the case of Ireland:
Very strong across the board, offset by significant deterioration in connectivity and technology infrastructure score (driven by new measurements of quality of broadband and mobile communications introduced in this year's rankings). Weak performance in consumer & business adoption - primarily on the back of economic crisis. Also weak performance in social & cultural environment, driven by education system shortcomings.

So to summarize:

• Ireland ranks 17th in connectivity & technology infrastructure, though broadband penetration remains low
• Ireland ranks 17th in business environment in tough market conditions
• Ireland ranks 17th in social & cultural environment despite low innovation scores compared to regional average
• Ireland ranks 22nd in legal environment, the main detractor is electronic ID implementation
• Ireland is in 21st place on Government policy & vision, the major challenge is in ICT spend
• Ireland is doing well and placed at 8th in consumer & business adoption
• Ireland has the lowest score drop in Western Europe from last year, which is only -0.02 (7.84 to 7.82)
• Ireland moved 1 rank up overall compared to 2009 (18 to 17), consumer & business adoption moved 4 ranks up and social & cultural environment up by 3 ranks
• Ireland has made a lot of progress in Government policy & vision scoring 8.40 and up 6 ranks, the progress is highest (+1.10) of all in Western Europe
• Broadband quality and affordability the weakest of connectivity category, scoring low on the quality and drop in affordability measurement
  

Economics 29/06/2010: EIU/IBM report on e-readiness

Global Digital Economy 2010 rankings are being launched today by the Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) and IBM's Institute for Business Value. Here are some early results - I will be blogging on more in-depth analysis over the next few days.

Global Top 10:
Sources: all charts and tables are from IBM analysis of EIU/IBM e-readiness rankings, 2010.

Western Europe results:

• Overall, regional digital economy score declined in 2010 – from 7.86 in 2009 to 7.70 this year
• The biggest score decline this year in the connectivity & technology infrastructure (-0.99), which is highest drop of all regions
• Sweden, Finland, Ireland and Spain are up in their overall ranks compared to last year
• The strength lies in all categories being at the top of all regional averages. Also, Western Europe average is higher than Major markets. The score increased for business environment (+0.20) & Govt policy (+0.18) from last year
• Western Europe dropped in all other 4 categories compared to last year (Connectivity, Social environment, Legal environment and Consumer & business adoption)
  

Note that Western Europe leads the rest of the world in terms of regional scores. This, however, in part is due to the inclusion of three smaller economies in North American region: Bermuda, Jamaica, Trinidad and Tobago.
Clearly, there are two well-defined tiers in Western European regional grouping - countries that score between 1 and 12 globally (challenging top 10 positions in the world) and those lagging at around mid-20s and low 30s.


Ireland results to follow, so stay tuned.