11/06/2011: Irish Competitiveness: latest data

Q4 2010 data for Euro area-wide competitiveness indicators is now out and it's worth updating my old charts and crunching through some numbers.

Remember - Irish and some European policymakers are quick to point to improving competitiveness as a core strength of Irish economy. I am slightly in a more skeptical camp on this. Improving competitiveness is good, but it matters where these improvements come from and whether our competitiveness is improving not in absolute terms, but relative to the rest of Euro zone. Let's take a look at what data tells us:

• Euro area Harmonized Competitiveness Indicator (unit labour cost-based) deteriorated in Q4 2010 to 97.9 from 96.3 in Q3 2010 (higher values reflect lower competitiveness). This means that qoq HCI for Euro area (the average benchmark to compare ourselves against) has deteriorated 1.66%, while yoy it is still showing improvement of 9.69%. For the 6mo from July through December 2010 Euro area competitiveness improved 9.55% on same period in 2009.
• Irish HCI has moved from 110.8 in Q3 2010 to 113.8 in Q4 2010 - a deterioration in competitiveness of 2.71% - much deeper drop than for the Euro area average. However, year on year we are still outpacing Euro area gains in competitiveness, with our competitiveness improving 10.60% on Q4 2009, against Euro area improvement of 9.69%. For the 6 mo through December 2010, Irish competitiveness improved 10.62% yoy again outpacing improvements in the Euro area at 9.55%.
• So the speed at which our competitiveness indicators are improving is about 16-17% faster compared to Euro area for the Q3-4 2010, but in Q4 our competitiveness has deteriorated about 10% faster than that of the Euro area.

Charts to illustrate:

This means that we have to think not only in terms of the rates of change, but in terms of actual levels of competitiveness. And here we are not exactly a shining example of a competitive economy:

• In Q3 2010, Ireland was the third least competitive economy in the Euro area, scoring 110.8 HCI reading against 111.7 for Luxembourg and 171.3 for Slovakia. In Q4 2010 we slipped down to the second least competitive economy ranking with 113.8 for Ireland, against 113 for Luxembourg. Not exactly where we would like to be, nor the direction we would like to be heading in. Especially since wages are not growing and unemployment is not improving, while overall employment is declining - in Ireland, while the opposite is true for many of our competitors. Which suggests that the value added of our output is declining to drive our HCIs readings up.
• More significantly, since Slovakia and Lux are not exactly our immediate comparators, as chart below shows, our performance remains extremely poor compared to other core Euro area economies.

So let's use the FF slogan from the past: "Lots done, more to do" to describe our situation. At the peak of our 'non-competitiveness', Irish HCI's exceeded Euro area reading by 25.9 points (Q1 2008). In Q4 2010, we exceeded Euro area benchmark by 15.9. Less than half of the gap in competitiveness has been erased by Ireland Inc. To get ourselves down to the level of our direct competitors (other Small Open Economies, SOE) we would need (assuming they stay put at Q4 2010 levels and excluding Slovakia and Ireland) to shave off roughly speaking another 8 points from our HCIs. In other words, you can think of this in the following terms - for all the pain we've experienced, we've traveled so far just under 56% of the road to becoming as competitive as the average other similar SOE. "Lots done, folks. Yet much left to do, still."