2/09/2011: Competitiveness in the long run: did the euro help?

Another look at the evolution of euro area competitiveness: in the chart below I plot ECB’s Harmonized Competitiveness Indicators for the euro area since 1995 as measured by the average annual HCIs deflated by unit labour costs. The higher the value of the index, the lower is competitiveness.

Here are some interesting points to observe, based on the data:

• The period since introduction of the euro witnessed deterioration or no improvement in overall competitiveness in all countries, save Germany, once the lags are accounted for (note, there is strong path dependency in many countries’ wages/labour costs due to long term contracts and generally sticky wages). Hence, for the period 1995-2001, euro area HCI averaged at 98.8, while for the period 2002-2010 the HCI averaged 99.8. Similarly, for France, HCI averages for the two sub-periods were 99.1 against 101.7, for Italy: 97.0 against 107.1, for Spain 98.4 against 108.3, for Finland, the Netherlands (Nordics) & Austria: 99.91 against 99.94 (statistically identical), for Ireland: 100.2 to 117.5 and for the rest of the euro area: 99.2 to 113.0.
• The period of highest competitiveness for all countries, except Germany, coincides with the period when pre-euro qualification period forces of improving competitiveness reach their peak: 2001-2002. This overall euro area competitiveness peaks in 2001, France’s competitiveness peaks in 2001, Italian, Spanish, Nordics’ & Austrian, Irish and Rest of euro area competitiveness peaked in 2001.
• After 2001, losses of competitiveness become pronounced across all economies, except Germany, with lowest competitiveness post-2000 points reached around 2008 (France, Spain and Ireland) or 2009 (all other countries, plus euro area as a whole).
• Since the onset of the crisis (again, accounting for lags) there have been significant gains in competitiveness. As I noted elsewhere, in some cases (Ireland and Spain, for example) these gains came primarily due to a wholesale destruction of a number of non-competitive domestic sectors (construction and retail).
• Gains in competitiveness have been very shallow in France (decline in HCI off the local pre-crisis peak of just 2.4%) and Italy (-3.2%), moderately weak in Germany (-5.22%), Nordics + Austria (-4.69%), Rest of Europe ex-Ireland (4.5%). Gains were close to euro area overall average (-9.2%) in Spain (-7.2%) and spectacularly strong in Ireland (-17.1%). It is worth noting once again that Irish gains in competitiveness came to a large extent from destruction of jobs in sectors that were least competitive before the bust (construction and domestic retailing and hospitality).
  

Overall influence of impressive German economic performance over the 2000s in terms of competitiveness can be clearly seen from the chart below.

But what the two charts above clearly suggest in terms of analysis for Ireland is really rather disturbing. Despite significant gains in competitiveness, Ireland remains well behind its peers in terms of absolute levels of HCIs – according to the latest data, we are lagging behind Germany, France, Italy, Spain, Finland, the Netherlands, Greece, Cyprus, Luxembourg, Malta, Austria, Portugal and Slovenia.

More importantly, delivering a similar magnitude decline over the next 2 years (a task that will either require unemployment rising to over 22% or a gargantuan effort in terms of productivity growth not seen in modern history of any state) will get us to the level of competitiveness comparable to 2001 – achieving HCI of ca 96.2.

It might be not bad, but should the trends across the other euro area countries also remain identical to those over the last 2 years, Ireland (with projected HCI under this scenario reaching 98.8) will be still less competitive than the euro area as a whole (92.9), Germany (82.8), the Nordics and Austria (98.7). If anyone expects this type of miracle to occur, good luck to them, but if anyone expects the result of this miracle to be a huge boost to our economic growth, let me point out the last little factoid that the data reveals: back in the 1990s our average HCI was 102.7 – below the euro area average of 104.2. With two consecutive ‘miracles’ we are not even aiming to get to parity of the euro area average.